Wednesday, April 22, 2009

Information as Cheeseburger

The argument Nicholas Carr makes on the difference between printed books and their digital counterparts (see Clutter)  rests on the idea that "A change in form is always...a change in content."

There is no question that the experience of reading a printed book is significantly different from the experience of reading an ebook, regardless of the device used in the process. But is the experience of reading an ebook or any long-form online content inherently distracting?  Or is the problem simply our failure to adapt to the new reading environment?

A reader is under no obligation to click a hypertext link that appears in the middle of a sentence. Nothing prevents a reader who wants to concentrate on an ebook or long online article from shutting down email and messaging applications  and taking other measures to create an environment conducive to reading and concentration.

Distraction is distraction, digital or otherwise. So isn't the issue really about getting better at tuning out -- or turning off -- the distractions?  Is reading a book on a crowded bus, train, or plane, with the various stimuli and distractions associated with those environments, so much less challenging than reading online? 

There is indeed a great deal of information clutter in our lives, and Mr. Carr's concerns certainly have merit. But blaming the inability to concentrate or a deterioration of intellectual or cognitive abilities on the availability of information is like blaming obesity on food.  Cheeseburgers and pizza are incapable of forcing themselves down your throat. Information is similarly constrained. The selection of what, when, and how much information we consume is a matter of making healthy choices based on the individual ability to metabolize that information.

Mr. Carr closes his post with the following comment on software writer Tim Bray's plans to digitize all of his books: 

When Tim Bray throws out his books, he may well have a neater, less dusty home. But he will not have reduced the clutter in his life, at least not in the life of his mind. He will have simply exchanged the physical clutter of books for the mental clutter of the web. He may discover, when he's carried that last armload of books to the dumpster, that he's emptied more than his walls.

Swapping a collection of books for a digitized, networked library is a matter of storage and interior decoration. And while such decisions can affect one's quality of life, they are a reflection of one's taste, not of one's capacity for critical thinking or intellectual prowess.  Mr. Carr appears to assume that Mr. Bray's decision will render him incapable of the levels of concentration and discrimination necessary to take advantage of an all-digital, on-demand library. That's just unfair.

Read:  Rough Type: Nicholas Carr's Blog: Clutter

 

Monday, March 16, 2009

James McGovern on the evolution of blogging

Writing in his Enterprise Architecture blog, James McGovern makes an interesting and disappointing observation about the state of blogging.

Recently, I have noticed much of my stimulus has changed. The blogosphere is moving away from conversations and towards simply using it as a platform to communicate thinly veiled media relations sanitized press releases where all forms of communications are void of conversation.

I have no problem with marketing people adopting blogging and other social media tools.  But it drives me up the freakin' wall when I see exactly what James McGovern describes.  Ultimately, those who treat social media as a collection of new tools for the same old crap will fail. Good riddance.

Read: Enterprise Architecture: From Incite comes Insight...

 

Thursday, March 12, 2009

The New Honesty...?

In a post on her small business blog, Rochell Paul admits to not yet using Twitter or Facebook or LinkedIn, and that's fine -- though I have to admit that I'm surprised that a small business blogger would be entering into the SM game this late. But that's not what I want to talk about.

What I want to talk about is this quote from her post:
We all need to understand that a major part of Social Media is transparency. Honesty. The idea that we are open and honest about our role, and intentions.
Of course, I agree completely with that statement. Who wouldn't? But I guess I'm just a bit flummoxed that this honesty and transparency business is treated as such a strange new idea in Web marketing. The Cluetrain Manifesto raised this issue a decade ago. I don't mean to single out Rochell in this; the information she presents in her post is worthwhile, and she is very upfront in her admission of social media newbie-osity. And she's certainly not the only blogger to address the issue.

But the big, obvious question is: why do honesty and transparency attract so much attention in the currently relentless discussion about social media? Why are honesty and transparency treated as innovative marketing concepts? Why do some people and some organizations struggle with those ideas? What does this say about "conventional" marketing practice?

Of course, Twitter and Facebook and other social media tools aren't immune to the kind of dishonesty and opacity that can make conventional marketing so annoying. So maybe posts like Rochell's deserve more credit than I'm giving them. Human nature being what it is, maybe we need to be reminded again and again that honesty is good marketing practice, that it's good, period.

Read Rochell's post: Twittering with honesty: being who you are on Twitter and Facebook

Saturday, February 28, 2009

Your Friends List: Does Size Matter?

 

What is the most effective use of Social Media as a marketing tool?  With regard to your list of friends, does size matter?

A recent article in The Economist (see Primates on Facebook) offers some interesting insight into Facebook usage and its correlation to the Dunbar Number, which suggests that the human brain is capable of maintaining connections to at most 150 people.

In the Economist article, Facebook sociologist Dr. Cameron Marlow offers some interesting statistics on the number and nature of the connections people make on the wildly popular social networking site:

Dr. Marlow found that the average number of "friends" in a Facebook network is 120, consistent with Dr Dunbar's hypothesis, and that women tend to have somewhat more than men. But the range is large, and some people have networks numbering more than 500, so the hypothesis cannot yet be regarded as proven.

What also struck Dr Marlow, however, was that the number of people on an individual's friend list with whom he (or she) frequently interacts is remarkably small and stable. The more "active" or intimate the interaction, the smaller and more stable the group.

Thus an average man—one with 120 friends—generally responds to the postings of only seven of those friends by leaving comments on the posting individual's photos, status messages or "wall". An average woman is slightly more sociable, responding to ten. When it comes to two-way communication such as e-mails or chats, the average man interacts with only four people and the average woman with six. Among those Facebook users with 500 friends, these numbers are somewhat higher, but not hugely so. Men leave comments for 17 friends, women for 26. Men communicate with ten, women with 16.

After reading this I could not help but think, yet again, about Matt Dickman's insightful explanation of the difference between conventional Web marketing and effective Social Media marketing. 

In Redefining reach; the new marketing equation, Matt describes conventional Web marketing as a process that relies on sending a message (let's call it what it is: spam) to 1 million people in the hopes of reaching 1000. Effective Social Media marketing is about personally reaching out to "100 who influence 1,000 who influence 10,000 who influence 1,000,000."

Matt Dickman's equation, Dr. Marlow's statistics, and the Dunbar Number add up to a something significant, a powerful message to those who see Social Media as nothing more than a new flavor of the same old process. We're on to something new, something that requires a real, personal connection to real, individual people, not just a big list of anonymous targets.

So the bottom line is that the size of your friends list isn't important. It's all about the quality of the connections you make, and what you do to maintain those connections. It's very definitely not business-as-usual.

 

Tuesday, February 24, 2009

A Future for Newspapers

Amid all the recent coverage of financial troubles at various newspapers, WSJ columnist L. Gordon Crovitz offers this:

One reason most media companies suspended normal business practices online, such as seeking subscription revenues, was a misinterpretation of one of the most powerful observations of the Information Age. When author Stewart Brand coined the expression "Information wants to be free," he focused on how technology makes it cheap and easy to communicate and share knowledge. But the rest of his quote is rarely noticed. This says, "Information also wants to be expensive." The right information in today's complex economy and society can make a huge difference in our professional and personal lives. Not having this information can also make a big difference, especially if someone else does have it. And for valuable information, online is a great new way for it to be valued.

I have subscriptions to the print editions of the New York Times, the Wall Street Journal, and the Cleveland Plain Dealer, though I most often read them online. My belief in and support of grassroots, social media-style journalism notwithstanding, newspapers still have a vital role to play, and I will happily pay for information that has value in my life.

Like any other business, however, newspapers must constantly strive for innovation in how they address the needs of their customers. If newspapers meet those needs, they should charge for that service. Their slice of the pie may be smaller, a factor that has already reshaped the industry and will continue to do so. But in age when we are awash in information, much of it of little consequence, the value of good information is at a premium, a premium that I'll happily pay.

 

Read the WSJ article: Information Wants to Be Expensive - WSJ.com